Mafia: The Old Country cover art. OFFICIAL ART
Cover image via IGDB, © 2K Games. · License: IGDB image hosting (editorial use)
ACTION-ADVENTURE·OPEN WORLD·REL 2025

Mafia: The Old Country’25

The Verdict GOOD 4 of 6 said it
Aggregate · creator panel
6 scored reviewers
Vote distribution
Positive3 Mixed2 Negative1
Source
// facts checked 2026-05-29 · mortismal gaming review, skill up review, igdb

Streamer verdicts

One bucket per creator — explicit picks plus inferred reads from their quotes

Review notes ·9

Verbatim quotes from indexed creators

Mortismal Gaming

GOOD
5:45 positive

I actually think this is a pretty good update. And while it's not perfect by any means, there's no like, you know, proper side quests or side content to do outside of these challenges.

2 earlier reviews from this creator
5:12 mixed

gameplaywise, it's not bad or anything. I'd say it's just a little run-of-the-mill. But as far as first impressions goes, that's pretty much where I'm at with it. I am enjoying it so far.

GOOD
8:33 positive

I hope we get more games like Mafia willing to subvert the notion that player freedom is the thing to chase above all else. The world of Mafia: The Old Country might be brutally restrictive, brutally violent, and ultimately illusory, but at least the game is honest.

GOOD
54:16 positive

I kind of like this actually. It's just a very chill game that's not getting bogged down with huge amounts of open world nonsense or anything. Instead, it's just a fairly small game that's very focused on the story it wants to tell. It's pretty. It's atmospheric. It tells a good story.

GOOD
2:33:12 mixed

I personally really really enjoyed Mafia the Old Country... I recommend that you play it if you like narrative games like this.

1 earlier review from this creator
5:21 positive

if you like the idea of a really good narrative, Mafia the Old Country seems to deliver it across the board... it's the gameplay where it's not breaking any boundaries... it does enough to keep you engaged over the course of a short 10 to 12 hour story, but ultimately you're playing it for the story.

MEH
SHIT
0:52 negative

it's slop. It's modern-day slop... it's a disgrace to mafia. It really is. And it's just typical of 2025 gaming.